G. M. . Azad, “THE HISTORY OF AL-ṬABARĪ (TĀRĪKH AL-RUSUL WA’L-MULŪK) VOL. II: PROPHETS AND PATRIARCHS by WILLIAM M. BRINNER;THE HISTORY OF AL-ṬABARĪ (TĀRĪKH AL-RUSUL WA’L-MULŪK), VOL. XVIII: BETWEEN CIVIL WARS: THE CALIPHATE OF MU’ĀWIYAH by MICHAEL G. MORONY;THE HISTORY”, IS, vol. 26, no. 04, pp. 377–380, Dec. 1987.