Non-Muslim Leadership and the Question of Legitimacy
A Critical Study on the Indonesian Case
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52541/isiri.v64i4.7254Keywords:
Indonesia, non-Muslim leadership, legitimacy, politics, religionAbstract
The issue of non-Muslim leadership within the Islamic community remains a highly debated topic in several Muslim countries, particularly those with diverse religious populations. While Muslim jurists have historically agreed that the head of state should be a Muslim, the political changes witnessed in Muslim societies and the establishment of modern nation states during the post-colonial era have led to the emergence of differing opinions regarding the permissibility of non-Muslim leadership. This study investigates Indonesia as a case study, considering its societal context marked by significant political and intellectual polarization. This context is characterized by ideological divisions among writers and the presence of competing organizations within the political sphere. To address this issue, this paper explores two main areas: firstly, it highlights the historical background surrounding the emergence of this problem both internationally and locally, and secondly, it evaluates the textual and jurisprudential evidence presented by proponents of non-Muslim leadership legitimacy. The evaluation of inference methods used to justify the legitimacy of a non-Muslim leadership reveals the adoption of an arbitrary approach in interpreting textual and jurisprudential evidence, which involves both selectivity and distortion.
References
Abdul Wakhid, Ali, Mohd Shahril Bin Ahmad Razimi, Moh. Mukri, and Is Susanto. “The Islamic Perspective of Non-Muslim Leaders in Indonesian Muslim Majority Communities.” Akademika 26, no. 2 (2021): 277-96. https://doi.org/10.32332/akademika.v26i2.3753.
Ahyar, Muzayyin, and Aksi Bela Islam. “Islamic Clicktivism and the New Authority of Religious Propaganda in the Millennial Age in Indonesia.” Indonesian Journal of Islam and Muslim Societies 9, no. 1 (2019): 1-29. https://doi.org/10.18326/ijims.v9i1.1-29.
Al-ʻAsqalānī, Aḥmad b. Ḥajar. Fatḥ al-Bārī Sharḥ Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī. Edited by Muḥibb al-Dīn al-Khaṭīb. Cairo: Dār al-Rayyān, 1987.
Al-ʻAynī, Maḥmūd. ʻAqd al-Jumān fī Ta’rīkh Ahl al-Zamān. Edited by Muḥammad Amīn. Cairo: Dār al-Kutub wa ’l-Wathāʼiq al-Qawmiyyah, 2010.
Ansell, Christopher K. “Legitimacy: Political.” In International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, edited by Neil J. Smelser and Paul B. Baltes, 8704-6. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2001.
B. Karyanto, Umum. “The Appointment of Non-Muslim Leaders (Study of Surah Al-Mâ’idah Verses 51 and 57 Using Semantic Approach).” Alsinatuna Journal 3 no. 1 (2017): 46-58. https://doi.org/10.28918/alsinatuna.v3i1.6755.
Beetham, David. The Legitimation of Power. New York: Palgrave, 2003.
Benard, Cheryl. Civil Democratic Islam: Partners, Resources, and Strategies. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 2003.
Brennan, Jason. Against Democracy. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2016.
Cerovac, Ivan. Epistemic Democracy and Political Legitimacy. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, 2020.
Coicaud, Jean-Marc. Legitimacy and Politics: A Contribution to the Study of Political Right and Political Responsibility, edited and translated by David Ames Curtis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002.
Crone, Patricia. God’s Rule: Government and Islam. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2004.
Ḥamīd Allāh, Muḥammad. Majmūʻ al-Wathāʼiq al-Siyāsiyyah li ’l-ʻAhd al-Nabawī wa ’l-Khilāfah al-Rāshidah. Beirut: Dār al-Nafāʼis, 1987.
Haq, Riaz. “Eight Non-Muslim Leaders in Muslim Majority Countries.” Accessed December 20, 2025. https://www.pakalumni.com/profiles/blogs/eight-non-muslim-leaders-in-muslim-majority-countries.
Herlijanto, Johanes. “Yusof Ishak Institute Analyze Current Events.” ISEAS Perspective, 52 (2017): 2.
Hidayat, Dede, Dody S. Truna, Mohammad Taufiq Rahman, Asep Muhyidin. “The Construction of Habib Rizieq Shihab’s Political Islamic Thought in the Post-Reform Indonesian Context.” Hanifiya: Jurnal Studi Agama-Agama 6, no. 2 (2023): 39-50.
Ibn al-Ṭiqṭaqī, Muḥammad b. ʻAlī. Al-Fakhrī fī ’l-Ādāb al-Sulṭāniyyah wa ’l-Duwal al-Islāmiyyah. Edited by ʻAbd al-Qādir Māyū. Beirut: Dār al-Qalam al-ʻArabī, 1997.
Ibn Taymiyyah, Aḥmad. Majmūʻ al-Fatāwā. Medina: Majmaʻ al-Malik Fahd li Ṭibāʻat al-Muṣḥaf al-Sharīf, 1995.
Iyengar, Shanto, Yphtach Lelkes, Matthew Levendusky, Neil Malhotra, and Sean J. Westwood. “The Origins and Consequences of Affective Polarization in the United States.” Annual Review of Political Science 22 (2019): 129-46. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-polisci-051117-073034.
Khalik, Abu Tholib. “Pemimpin Non-Muslim Dalam Perspektif Ibnu Taimiyyah.” ANALISIS: Jurnal Studi Keislaman 14, no. 1 (2014): 59-89.
Land, Nick. The Dark Enlightenment. Perth: Imperium Press, 2022.
Makrum, Makrum. “On Muslim Voting for non-Muslim Leaders, A Qur’anic Perspective.” Epistemé 14, no. 2 (2019): 235-51. https://doi.org/10.21274/epis.2019.14.2.235-251.
Maksum, Ali. “Discourses on Islam and Democracy in Indonesia: A Study on the Intellectual Debate between Liberal Islam Network (JIL) and Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia (HTI).” Journal of Indonesian Islam 11, no. 2 (2017): 405-22. https://doi.org/10.15642/JIIS.2017.11.2.405-422.
Menchik, Jeremy. Islam and Democracy in Indonesia: Tolerance without Liberalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016.
Miichi, Ken. “Islamic Youth Movements in Indonesia.” IIAS Newsletter 32 (November 2003): 22. https://www.iias.asia/sites/default/files/2020-11/IIAS_NL32_22.pdf.
Nasr, Vali. “Secularism: Lessons from the Muslim World.” Daedalus 132, no. 3 (2003): 67-72.
Netelenbos, Benno. Political Legitimacy beyond Weber: An Analytical Framework. London: Springer Nature, 2016.
Rabasa, Angel M. et al, U.S. Strategy in the Muslim World After 9/11. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 2004.
Rabasa, Angel. Building Moderate Muslim Networks. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 2007.
Ramadhan, Muhammad, Bambang Saputra, and Adhia Nugraha. “Appointing non-Muslim Leadership Based on Fiqh Siyasah Perspective and the Implementation in Indonesia.” International Journal on Language, Research and Education Studies 4, no. 1 (2020): 104-17.
Riwanda, Agus, and Sanusi Ulath. “Secular State, NKRI Bersyariah, and NU’s Civilization Fiqh: Navigating the Dynamics of Sharia-State Relations and the Role of Political Parties in Indonesia,” ADDIN 18, no. 2 (2024): 157-92.
Robert, Gurr Ted. Why Men Rebel. New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1970.
Runciman, David. How Democracy Ends. London: Profile Books, 2018.
Salim, Arskal. Challenging the Secular State: The Islamization of Law in Modern Indonesia. Hawaii: University of Hawaii Press, 2008.
Salim, Delmus Puneri. “The Islamic Political Supports and Voting Behaviors in Majority and Minority Muslim Provinces in Indonesia.” Indonesian Journal of Islam and Muslim Societies 12, no. 1 (2022): 85-110. https://doi.org/10.18326/ijims.v12i1.85-110.
Seeth, Amanda tho. “‘Electing a President is Islamic Worship’—The Print Media Discourse of Azyumardi Azra during Reformasi (1998–2004).” Archipel Études interdisciplinaires sur le monde insulindien 101 (2021): 209-44. https://doi.org/10.4000/archipel.2404.
Sutomo, Imam, and Budihardjo. “The Rejection of Religious Nationalism towards the Secular State and the Islamic Caliphate: Indonesian Religious Figures Perspective.” Indonesian Journal of Islam and Muslim Societies 11, no. 1 (2021): 115-37. https://doi.org/10.18326/ijims.v11i1.115-137.
Vermonte, Philips. Islamic Ideas versus Secularism: The Core of Political Competition in Indonesia. West Jakarta: BINUS University, 2017.
Woodward, Mark, Ali Amin, Inayah Rohmaniyah, and Chris Lundry. “Getting Culture: A New Path for Indonesia’s Islamist Justice and Prosperity Party?” Contemporary Islam 7 (2013): 173-89, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11562-012-0187-x.
Woodward, Mark, and Rohmaniyah Inayah. “The Tawdry Tale of ‘Sheikh’ Puji and Luftiana: Child Marriage and Polygamy in Indonesian Discourse.” Musāwa 8, no. 2 (2009): 259-82.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Publication of material in the journal means that the author assigns copyright to Islamic Studies including the rights to electronic publishing. This is, inter alia, to ensure the efficient handling of requests from third parties to reproduce articles as well as to enable wide dissemination of the published material. Authors may, however, use their material in other publications acknowledging Islamic Studies as the original place of publication. Requests by third parties for permission to reprint should be addressed to the Editor, Islamic Studies.
