A Polemical Critique of Philosophical Heresies
The Maqāmi‘ al-Ḥadīd of Aḥmad Riḍā Khān
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52541/isiri.v64i4.7093Abstract
This article examines Maqāmi‘ al-Ḥadīd, a little-studied treatise by Aḥmad Riḍā Khān (d. 1921), one of the most influential Sunni scholars of colonial India, as a polemical critique of philosophical doctrines deemed heretical by Islamic orthodoxy. Through a detailed analysis of Khān’s refutation of eight propositions drawn from the Aristotelian-Avicennian philosophical tradition, the study highlights Khān’s broader antagonism towards philosophy as a discipline he saw as corrosive to Islamic belief and religious certainty. By situating Maqāmi‘ al-Ḥadīd within the wider context of Khān’s writings and the colonial educational reforms of nineteenth-century British India, the article suggests how his rejection of philosophy may be part of a larger intellectual and pedagogical resistance to a broader colonial modernity. Khān’s critique reflects deep anxieties about epistemological authority, the integrity of Islamic knowledge, and the threat of secular rationalism to Muslim identity and religious life. In challenging recent portrayals of Khān as exhibiting a significant affinity for philosophy, this article argues instead that his polemics against philosophy were a conscious act of intellectual and cultural preservation in an era of profound transformation.
References
‘Alī, Maulavī Raḥmān. Tadhkirah-i ‘Ulamā’-i Hind. Translated by Muḥammad Ayyūb Qādirī. Karachi: Pakistan Historical Society, 1961.
‘Alī, Maulavī Raḥmān. Tadhkira-i ‘Ulamā’-i Hind. Lucknow: Maṭba‘-i Munshī Naval Kishōr, 1914.
‘Aṭṭārī, Muḥammad Asad Qādirī. Talkhīṣ-i Fatāvā-i Riżaviyah. Lahore: Akbar Publishers, 2010.
Ahmad, Aijaz. Indian Muslims Against British Rule. New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company, 2014.
Al-Bihārī, Ẓafar al-Dīn. Ḥayāt-i A‘lā Ḥażrat. Lahore: Maktabah-i Nūriyyah, 2003.
Al-Ḥasanī, Al-Sharīf ‘Abd al-Ḥayy b. Fakhr al-Dīn. Al-I‘lām bi Man fī Ta’rīkh al-Hind min al-A‘lām al-Musammā bi Nuzhat al-Khawāṭir wa Bahjat al-Masāmi‘ wa ’l-Nawāẓir, 8 vols. Beirut: Dār Ibn Ḥazm, 1999.
Al-Mar‘ashlī, Yūsuf b. ‘Abd al-Raḥmān. Nathr al-Jawāhir al-Durar fī ‘Ulamā’ al-Qarn al-Rābi‘ ‘Ashar. (Beirut: Dār al-Ma‘rifah, 2006.
Al-Murādābādī, Sayyid Muḥammad Na‘īm al-Dīn. Khazā’in al-‘Irfān on the margins of Aḥmad Riḍā Khān’s Kanz al-Īmān. Karachi: Maktabat al-Madīnah, 2011.
Al-Sanbhalī, Muḥammad Ḥasan, Al-Manṭiq al-Jadīd li Nāṭiq wa Alannā lahu ’l-Ḥadīḍ (The New Discourse for the Eloquent One for Whom We Softened Iron). n.p.: Maṭba‘-i Anvār-i Muḥammadī, 1295/1878.
Al-Sanbhalī, Muḥammad Ḥasan. Al-Qawl al-Wasīt fī Ja‘l al-Mu’allaf wa ’l-Basīṭ (The Moderate Discourse on the Creation of Composite and Simple Substances. Kanpur: Maṭba‘-i Niẓāmī, 1879.
Andani, Khalil. “Divine Unicity (Tawḥīd).” In St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology, edited by Brendan N. Wolfe et al. August 29, 2024. https://www.saet.ac.uk/Islam/DivineUnicity.
Biesterfeldt, Hinrich. “Reflection: ‘Eternalists’ and ‘Materialists’ in Islam: A Note on the Dahriyya.” In Eternity: A History, edited by Yitzhak Y. Melamed, 117-23. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.
Brunschvig, Robert. “Mutazilisme et Optimum.” Studia Islamica 39 (1974): 5-23.
Burge, Stephen. “Angels (Malā’ika).” In St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology, edited by Brendan N. Wolfe et al. August 29, 2024. https://www.saet.ac.uk/Islam/Angels.
Chowdhury, Safaruk Zaman. Islamic Theology and the Problem of Evil. Cairo: American University in Cairo Press, 2021.
Crisp, Thomas. “Presentism.” In The Oxford Handbook of Metaphysics, edited by Michael J. Loux and Dean Zimmerman, 211-45. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003.
Hanif, N. Isam and Modernity. New Delhi: Sarup & Sons, 1997.
Hasan, Qamar. Muslims in India: Attitudes, Adjustments and Reactions. New Delhi: Northern Book Centre, 1987.
Ingram, Brannon D. “‘Modern’ Madrasa: Deoband and Colonial Secularity.” Historical Social Research 44 (2019): 206-25.
Ingram, Brannon. “Deoband School.” In Encyclopaedia of Indian Religions: Islam, Judaism and Zoroastrianism, edited by Zayn R. Kassam, Yudit Kornberg Greenberg and Jehan Bagli, 208-13. Dordrecht: Springer, 2018.
Ingram, David. “Presentism and Eternalism.” In The Routledge Companion to the Philosophy of Time, edited by Nina Emery, 197-208. London: Routledge, 2026.
Khān, Aḥmad Riḍā. ‘Ilm-o Ta‘līm. In al-‘Aṭāyā al-Nabawiyyah fī ’l-Fatāwā al-Riḍawiyyah, 23:623-720. Lahore: Riza Foundation, 2004.
Khān, Aḥmad Riḍā. Al-Ḥuqūq li Ṭarḥ al-‘Uqūq. In al-‘Aṭāyā al-Nabawiyyah fī ’l-Fatāwā al-Riḍawiyyah, 24:383-449. Lahore: Riza Foundation, 2004.
Khān, Aḥmad Riḍā. Al-Kalimah al-Mulhamah fī ’l-Ḥikmah al-Muḥkamah li Wihā’ al-Falsafah al-Mash’amah. In al-‘Aṭāyā al-Nabawiyyah fī ’l-Fatāwā al-Riḍawiyyah, 27:383-580. Lahore: Riza Foundation, 2004.
Khān, Aḥmad Riḍā. Maqāmi‘ al-Ḥadīd ‘alā Khadd Manṭiq al-Jadīd. In al-‘Aṭāyā al-Nabawiyyah fī ’l-Fatāwā al-Riḍawiyyah, 105-94. Lahore: Riza Foundation, 2004.
Khān, Aḥmad Riḍā. Qawāri‘ al-Qahhār ‘alā ’l-Mujassimah al-Fujjār. In al-‘Aṭāyā al-Nabawiyyah fī ’l-Fatāwā al-Riḍawiyyah, 29:119-285. Lahore: Riza Foundation, 2004.
Kugler, Thomas J. “Barelwīs.” In Encyclopaedia of Indian Religions: Islam, Judaism and Zoroastrianism, edited by Zayn R. Kassam, Yudit Kornberg Greenberg, and Jehan Bagli, 116-20. Dordrecht: Springer, 2018.
Maheshwari, Anil, and Richa Singh. Syncretic Islam: The Life and Times of Ahmad Raza Khan Barelvi. New Delhi: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2021.
Mir, Mustansir. “Polytheism and Atheism.” In Encyclopaedia of the Qur’ān, edited by Jane Dammen McAuliffe, 4:158-62. Leiden: Brill, 2004.
Muḥammad Ḥanīf Khān, ed. Jahān-i Imām Aḥmad Riżā Khān. 20 vols. Lahore: Shabbir Brothers, 2019.
Naeem, Fuad S. “Sufism and Revivalism in South Asia: Mawlānā Ashraf ‘Alī Thanvī of Deoband and Mawlānā Aḥmad Razā Khān of Bareilly and Their Paradigms of Islamic Revivalism.” The Muslim World 99 (2009): 435-51.
Nu‘mānī, Muḥammad ‘Abd al-Mubīn. Al-Muṣannafāt al-Riḍawiyyah, 2nd ed. Malegaon: Nuri Mission, 2013.
Ozalp, Mehmet. God in Islamic Theology: Tawhid in Classical Islamic Theology and Said Nursi’s Risale-i Nur. London: Lexington Books, 2023.
Qādirī, Jalāl al-Dīn. Imām Aḥmad Riżā kā Naẓariyah-i Ta‘līm. Lahore: Markazī Majlis-i Riżā, 1984.
Qādirī, Muḥammad ‘Abd al-Ḥakīm Sharaf. Yād-i A‘lā Ḥażrat. Lahore: Maktabah-i Qādiriyyah, 1994.
Qādirī, Muḥammad Isḥāq. “Imām Aḥmad Riżā Khān kī Manṭiqiyānah aur Falsafiyānah Fikr-o Naẓar.” In Jahān-i Imām Aḥmad Riżā Khān, edited by Muḥammad Ḥanīf Khān. Lahore: Shabbir Brothers, 2019.
Riḍā, Muḥammad Jalāl, and Ghulām Muḥammad Butt. Al-Falsafah wa ’l-Islām. Cairo: Dār al-Bayān li ’l-Nashr wa ’l-Tawzī‘, 2002.
Riżavī, Muḥammad ‘Alā’ al-Dīn. “Imām Aḥmad Riżā aur ‘Aṣrī Ta‘līm.” In Jahān-i Imām Aḥmad Riżā Khān, edited by Muḥammad Ḥanīf Khān. Lahore: Shabbir Brothers, 2019.
Rouzati, Nasrin. “The Concept of Evil in Islam.” In The Concept of Evil in Judaism, Christianity and Islam, edited by Georges Tamer and Catherina Rachik, 101-52. Berlin: Walter De Gruyter, 2024.
Sa‘d Allāh, Muḥammad. ‘Aqīdah-i Tauḥīd maiṇ Maulānā Aḥmad Riżā Khān kī Khidmāt. Lahore: Dār al-Ikhlāṣ, 2009.
Sajjad, Mohammad Waqas. “For the Love of the Prophet: Deobandi-Barelvi Polemics and the Ulama in Pakistan.” PhD diss., Faculty of Graduate Theological Union, Berkeley, California, 2018.
Sanyal, Usha. Ahmad Riza Khan Barelwi: In the Path of the Prophet. Oxford: Oneworld Publications, 2005.
Sanyal, Usha. Devotional Islam and Politics in British India: Ahmad Riza Khan Barelwi and His Movement, 1870-1920. New Delhi: Yoda Press, 2010.
Shaikh, M. S. Saeed. A Dictionary of Muslim Philosophy. Lahore: Institute of Islamic Culture, 1970.
Shourie, Arun. The World of Fatwas or the Shariah in Action. New Delhi: HarperCollins, 2012.
Sikand, Yoginder. Bastions of the Believers: Madrasas and Islamic Education in India. New Delhi: Penguin Books India, 2005.
Tareen, SherAli. Defending Muḥammad in Modernity. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 2020.
Wajihuddin, Mohammed. Aligarh Muslim University: The Making of the Modern Indian Muslim. New Delhi: HarperCollins, 2021.
Winter, Timothy. “Evil and Suffering.” In St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology, edited by Brendan N. Wolfe. et al. August 29, 2024, https://www.saet.ac.uk/Islam/EvilandSuffering.
Zaman, Muhammad Qasim. The Ulema in Contemporary Islam: Custodians of Change. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2002.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Publication of material in the journal means that the author assigns copyright to Islamic Studies including the rights to electronic publishing. This is, inter alia, to ensure the efficient handling of requests from third parties to reproduce articles as well as to enable wide dissemination of the published material. Authors may, however, use their material in other publications acknowledging Islamic Studies as the original place of publication. Requests by third parties for permission to reprint should be addressed to the Editor, Islamic Studies.
